
A lot of people put off getting their coins appraised because they aren’t sure what to expect. Will it take all day? Will they be pressured to sell? Do they need to organize everything first? Here’s a step-by-step look at what an appraisal at our counter actually involves — no mystery, and no obligation.
Before you come in
Walk in or book ahead
No appointment is required. Walk-ins are welcome during business hours. If you’d like an expert ready the moment you arrive, you can reserve a time through the scheduler on our Appraisals page or by calling the shop.
Leave things as they are
There’s no need to clean, sort, or organize anything. In fact, please don’t clean your coins — original surfaces matter, and cleaning can reduce value. If coins are in certified holders, albums, or original mint packaging, bring them just as they are. Any paperwork, receipts, or certificates you have are helpful, too.
At the counter
Step 1: We sort what you brought
We start by separating bullion from collectible coins and identifying each piece — the type, date, mint mark, and country of origin. For a large estate, this first pass helps us focus our time on the pieces that deserve a closer look.
Step 2: Bullion is weighed and priced
Bullion bars, rounds, and bullion coins are weighed and priced against the live spot market. Their appraisal is about metal content, and we’ll show you how the math works.
Step 3: Collectible coins are graded
Collectible coins are examined under magnification and graded against PCGS and NGC standards. We look at wear, strike, luster, surface marks, and any signs of cleaning or damage. Dealers commonly use tools like precision scales, calipers, and magnification for this, and we explain what we’re looking at as we go.
Step 4: We check current market values
Grade and rarity only mean something next to what comparable coins are bringing in today’s market. We compare against current values so your numbers reflect the real market, not an old price guide.
Understanding the numbers
For coins, you may hear about more than one kind of value. Retail, or replacement, value is what it might cost to buy a similar coin. Wholesale value is what dealers pay one another. Scrap value is metal content alone. For bullion, the figure is simply market value. Knowing which number you’re looking at keeps expectations realistic.
Step 5: You decide
Once everything is evaluated, you’ll know exactly what we’re offering and why. Our verbal appraisals are always free, with no obligation to sell. Accept the offer and walk out paid the same day, or take time to think — it’s entirely your call.
Ready when you are
Bring your coins, bullion, jewelry, or diamonds to All Valley Coin & Jewelry at 28480 Old Town Front St, Suite C, Temecula, CA 92590. We’re open Monday through Friday 10am–5pm and Saturday 9:30am–5pm. Walk in, or call (951) 757-0334 to book a time.
